Re-Response to Alive!, Q1
I asked Alive! what his 5 favorite albums were. He responded.
I will answer the question myself. Then it’s his turn to ask. I answer; he answers. Then it’s my turn. You get the drill.
So now it’s my turn to answer my question. When I posed the question, I’d completely forgotten about the obvious nod to *High Fidelity*. I guess I watched that movie so many times as a teenager that it’s burning into my cerebral cortex and bubbles up without me even knowing about it.
Now that the barrel of the gun is aimed at me, I realize what a hard question this is. Well, sort of. My top 3 have been safe for several years now. It’s everything else. Picking #4 and #5 meant leaving out many, many favorites. So here, in rapid succession, is a brief (and probably incomplete) rundown of the Honorable Mentions.
~Jeff Buckley, Grace (Such a phenomenal album. He sounds like a rebel angel. This barely missed the cut.)
~Sigur Ros, ( ) (So beautiful and dark and wandering. Music to listen to alone at night as you think about things. For some reason, the first track will make me randomly weep from time to time. Something about the sound structure of the song–particularly in the few moments where the music bursts forth–taps into a feeling of nostalgia for childhood and thus a stark knowledge of mortality.)
~Guns N Roses, Appetite for Destruction (This was the first album I ever bought, I’m proud to say. Still kicks so much ass after all these years. They never put out another album nearly as good or complete.)
~Miles Davis, In a Silent Way and Sketches of Spain (I like these both so much I don’t know how to choose between them. I’d pick Bitches Brew but I am going to leave it off both out of respect for Alive!–who loves, loves, loves it–and to protest that inexplicably dumb choice to leave “Recollections,” one of my favorite songs ever, off the final album.)
~The Beatles, The White Album (I might have listened to this album more than any other. It has a little bit of everything. I’m not sure why I left it off. Get rid of the pretentious Revolution #9 and maybe it’s in.)
~Bach’s Cello Suites, performed by Pablo Casals (These are old recordings from the first half of the 20th c. Yo-Yo Ma has our a version of these glorious pieces that is beautiful yet somehow sterile. All technical perfection without any passion. Pablo Casals, on the other hand, probably isn’t as good as Yo-Yo Ma–not that I’d really know how to judge this–but he infuses the music with an immense amount of feeling.)
~Bruce Springsteen, Born to Run and The Wild, The Innocent, and the E Street Shuffle (I love the Boss. More on this later.)
~Rolling Stones, Exile on Main St. (My favorite album by them–although this is hardly an unusual feeling. A lovely mixture of rock n roll, blues, sex, drugs, and moxie. The opening song is my favorite by them, and it features what is probably my all-time favorite rock n roll line, “The sunshine bores the daylights out of me.”)
~U2, The Unforgettable Fire (Such a good album. This was back when U2 was so very good that they built up a reputation on which they’re still coasting today. “MLK” is one of my favorite songs.)
~Tom Waits, Rain Dogs (I could put a bunch of Tom Waits albums on here. But I think this one is my favorite. The hoarse, rueful cries on “Anywhere I Lay My Head” give me goosebumps every time.)
~Bob Dylan, Blood on the Tracks (Leaving this one off–my favorite Bob Dylan album featuring my favorite DB song, “Tangled Up in Blue”–rather hurt.)
I could go on. But these are some I wanted to recognize some big-time favorites. And now for the main attraction.
#5: Radiohead, OK Computer. This album is a monster. Every single some kicks ass–well, I’m partial to “Fitter Happier,” but I know some people who dislike it–and a few of them are remarkable. I’m thinking of “Airbag,” “Paranoid Android,” “Exit Music (For a Film),” “Karma Police,” “Climbing Up the Walls,” and “No Surprises.” That’s half the album! I can recall the first time I heard it and how I thought, with that first listen, that this album was astonishing. It captured paranoia, disaffection, and alienation and made it beautiful, stirring. It’s been out for over a decade now. I will admit that I’m a big fan of Kid A and In Rainbows, but they haven’t done anything close to this.
#4: Joni Mitchell, Blue. A friend of mine from high school would be pleased with this selection, as she was a big Joni fan, and I was a big Rolling Stones fan and scoffed at her. But I hadn’t listened to the music. Then I did, and I quickly started singing another tune. I will admit that her quivering voices gets a touch too maudlin once or twice, and that few of her lyrics clomp along (“But when he’s gone / Me and them lonesome blues collide. / The bed’s too big, / The frying pan’s too wide”) or (“I’ll go see some folks I dig, / I’ll even kiss a sunset pig.”), but those are easily corralled into the larger wonder of the album: its raw–and perhaps even honest–representation of love, caring, heartbreak, and so on. I can permit a few blemishes, given the thorny subject matter. “All I Want” is the best song ever written about love–period, end of story, next question; I don’t even want to debate this. “Carey” is a lovely song about sweet things that tucks its sadness into the edges of the song (“You’re a mean old daddy but I like you”). The line “I could drink a case of you / A still be on my feet” is about the sexist line I’ve ever heard. The way her voice trails off at the end of “River” will kill me for as long as I live. It’s a beautiful album. I admire several of her albums–particularly Ladies of the Canyon, and Court and Spark–but neither get to me like this. Everybody hurts; everybody goes through hard times. Very rarely does anyone turn them into something this marvelous.
#3: Miles Davis, Kind of Blue. I don’t think I have to say too much about this one. What a line up of musicians! What a collection of songs! I could listen to it again and again and again and again and again and again. It’s an obvious choice–but that doesn’t make it wrong! It’s not its fault it’s great!
#2: Bruce Springsteen, Greetings from Asbury Park, N.J. Born to Run was Boss’ third album. It was super-famous: the band went international; he became the first person who wasn’t a world leader to appear on the covers of both Time and Newsweek in the same cycle; he single-handedly killed disco, some say. Born to Run yielded several hits, and its a juggernaut of an album in its own right. But what some people don’t realize is that Boss and the E Street Band released two albums before Born to Run–and both of them are fucking fantastic. The Wild, the Innocent, and the E Street Shuffle, their second album, teems with joy, sensuality, and youthful vigor. Seriously, listen to “Rosalita (Come Out Tonight)” and tell me that’s not a wonderful, exuberant song; only a young man at the beginning of his career could get away with a song like that, and Boss pulls it off with an easy grin. But the real gem, in my mind, is Greetings from Asbury Park, N.J.–the cover is a postcard, hence the title–which is the Boss’ first album. First track: Blinded by the Light, made famous in a heavily cut version by Manfred Mann. Boss’ version is even better. Songs like “Growing Up” and “For You” are youthful songs, but the green comes out with the rush of words and spontaneity. Old Boss has become a master of sparse, haunting lyrics; young Boss is like Bob Dylan on acid. Some of the lines don’t make any sense but they sure do sound nice. Here, for example, are the first two lines of “Blinded by the Light”: “Madmen drummers bummers and Indians in the summer with a teenage diplomat / In the dumps with the mumps as the adolescent pumps his way into his hat.” “Growing Up” captures the spirit of defiant teenage rebellion about as well as anything I’ve heard. “Does This Bus Stop at 82nd Street” has no chorus–or really any sense of narrative–but remains an enthralling rush of words and images. “Spirit in the Night” begins with one of my favorite opening images: “Crazy Janey and her mission man were back in the alley tradin’ hands / Along came Wild Billy and his friend G-man all duded up for Saturday night / Billy slammed on his coaster brakes and said anybody wanna go on up to greasy lake / It’s about a mile down on the dark side of route 88 / I got a bottle of Rose so let’s try it.” Boss knows how to write a song. But my favorite track is the last, “It’s Hard to Be a Saint in the City.” If you’ve never heard it, give it a shot. It’s an excellent and highly underrated album.
#1: Van Morrison, Astral Weeks. This has been my favorite album since high school, when a kindly teacher lent it to me and it took the top off my head. The scales fell from my eyes. And so forth. I’d never heard anything like it. To this day, I’ve never heard anything like it. Van’s put out some excellent albums–his early stuff is his best stuff, I think, but he’s an astonishingly long and productive career, much like Boss, Neil Young, Tom Waits, Elvis Costello, etc.–but this is a cut above the rest. Every song is brilliant; every song is appreciably different and intriguing. Lyrically, this album is top-notch. Here’s the opening snippet of the first song: “If I ventured in the slipstream / Between the viaducts of your dream / Where immobile steel rims crack / And the ditch in the back roads stop / Could you find me? Woudl you kiss-a my eyes? / Lay me down / In silence easy / To be born again.” It sets the tone—the album has often been thought of as a musical form of impressionism–and already we can see Van’s lyrical chops. This is his first solo album; he means to impress. Van’s voice has a harsh cadence that I realize can be off-putting to some, but here it can soar to ecstasy (listen to the lift-off of “And you’re high on your high-flyin’ cloud” in “Beside You”) or dip to a plaintive growl (the devastating last lines of “Slim Slow Slider,” which is certainly on my shortlist of all-time favorite songs); or, in other words, the harsh cadence is used to achieve certain emotive ends. The album is full of unexpected musical touches: the hoo-boy! humming guitar lick at the end of “Astral Weeks; the bass-line in “The Way Young Lovers Do” that just a touch too fast and thus of sync, creating an underlayer of uncertainty and confusion; the wistful flute in “Slim Slow Slider.” But, above all, I adore how Van uses his voice in unusual ways. The grunts, the murmurs, the chortles, the sighs–they happen frequently (especially in live performances) and always contribute. He lets loose this concealed laugh–the kind of light laugh one lets out when thinking about something very sad–in “Slim Slow Slider” that just slays me every single time I hear it. The way he repeats “eye” in “Madame George.” The way his voice quivers with anticipation in “Cyprus Avenue.” I love this album to pieces. I cannot foresee something knocking if off the podium. If you haven’t heard it–or even if you haven’t heard in awhile–give it a listen; it has my highest possible recommendation.

